Continuing her series of articles on the history of social activism at the Chelsea Hotel, Sherrill Tippins, author of the upcoming Dream Palace, a history of the Chelsea, writes:

William Dean Howells, former editor of Boston's prestigious Atlantic Monthly, stayed at the Chelsea as he was moving to New York in order to write for Harper's magazines and lead the development of American literature in New York. At the Chelsea in 1888, he read Looking Backward, the utopian novel by his Massachusetts protege, Edward Bellamy. Bellamy's vision of a Henry-George-type society in which all natural resources are owned by the state, reducing the waste of private enterprise and freeing 200px-William_Dean_Howells citizens from penury, covetousness, and neglected talents, changed Howells's life.  Previously a comfortable armchair liberal, Howells became an angry activist for social justice–pushing the cause of literary realism as a tool for creating social change, writing his own realistic novels addressing the damaging issue of real estate prices in New York; the plight of factory workers in Massachusetts; the rising anger of the working class in downtown Manhattan, etc.  He embarrassed his upper-class friends with his sarcastic columns in Harper's criticizing American imperialism in Cuba and the Philippines, railing against the executions of the alleged conspirators in Chicago's Haymarket riot, and praising Tolstoy's socialist ideas. (In 1892 he also wrote a novel titled The Coast of Bohemia that captures the atmosphere of the Chelsea, and of the city's social and artistic changes, in the late 1880s.)  But in the end, Howells was unable to venture fully out of his fastidious middle-class worldview. It would take years for another shabby young protege, Stephen Crane, to persuade Howells to actually venture inside some of the miserable tenement apartments on the Lower East Side–and to show the older writer how a truly realistic New York novel like Crane's own Maggie: A Girl of the Streets really could create social change.

Posted in

6 responses to “Activism at the Chelsea Hotel Pt. II: William Dean Howells, Employed Literary Realism as a Tool for Change”

  1. Bernie Got Mine Avatar

    Sherill,
    Thanks for the post. I didn’t know the Chelsea even existed before the Krauss family became involved. Anyway, I’m sure history will be kind to the Krauss lineage. The Gross family — not so sure.
    xoxo

    Like

  2. Edward J. Dodson Avatar

    I would like to point out that Henry George was not a proponent of the state ownership of land or land nationalization. He argued, as did Thomas Paine among others, that those who controlled land were the beneficiaries of a form of privilege for which the community (or society) deserved compensation. Paine referred to the payment due as “ground rent” and Henry George explained that the amount of ground rent due was to be determined by market forces.

    Like

  3. Sherill Tippins Avatar
    Sherill Tippins

    True, and I apologize. In an effort to condense, and to relate this installment to an earlier one, I conflated two ideas in a confusing way. Edward Dobson, I would be interesting in talking with you sometime. I assume I can contact you at the Henry George School of Social Science?

    Like

  4. Coup de Grace Avatar
    Coup de Grace

    Howells sounds like my kind of guy. Speaks out against hostile takeovers [of sovereign countries, at least], and violent expressions of authority. A very good thing for him that he missed the last eighteen months at the Chelsea – and a serving of both.

    Like

  5. Slumming Avatar
    Slumming

    Can you imagine if Crane had persuaded Howells to actually reside in the tenements, even for a night? Its how I like to picture Marlene being forced to live at the Chelsea as part of an anti-harassment program designed for slumlords. She would absolutely wither on twenty third street.
    Biz whiz that she iz, she’d be marketing aerosol cans of bohemian repellent within hours.

    Like

  6. Cheryl Meiers Avatar
    Cheryl Meiers

    Dear Sherill,
    Thanks for February House, very interesting and absorbing! Someone (maybe you?) should write about Mike Todd’s romantic history, he comes up a lot in other people’s stories, even in Linda Goodman’s astrology books….

    Like

Leave a comment